So, how do we define "Standard of Finish"? What is a "Best Finish?" Is it like famous quote re: pornography " I can't define it but I know it when I see it? "

Do we start with the various components eg barrels: barrel striking, blacking, soldering, chopper lump, proof, balance, and so on? How about a sunburst or the engraving?

How about the internals? Gilding is a plus but is it a sufficient condition to get in the first tier?

Maybe some gunmaker can state what the standard of finish should be to be a Best Finish?

I know you are out there.....

Snowing here in NH