The most important thing is how well they fit YOU! Both are fine guns and will digest any ammo you put in them. I generally prefer the LC, but my light gun is a Lindner which fits me perfectly and as it is too early for Super X type loads (and is 5 1/2#) I use lighter loads. Both your guns are past the 2 9/16" era, so no problem there.
So bottom line remains...How do they fit YOU?!