Brian:

I'm sure to be the outlier here, but I'd go with the .30-30. I've looked at it a bunch and am still thinking about pulling the trigger on one. I'm sure that you could kill a moose with a well-constructed 165 grain .30 caliber bullet, even at 2200 fps and you could handload spitzers for the DR.

Besides, I want someone to buy one and report on it so I can make up my mind about buying one.

Rem