The dent is nothing--a good smith can take it out so you won't notice. The non-original recoil pad takes $$ away, especially if the stock has been cut. As is, a dealer might give you $5K for it. For cash at a show, look for $6-7K if you want to move it, $8K if you don't care. A dealer would either put the correct buttplate on if the stock hadn't been cut, or put a period correct Silvers pad if it had, and try to move it for $10K. It might sit there for a while at that price. As a shooter, the competition is the Parker Repro 28's that are selling for about $5500 all over the place. With a cut stock, there isnt much additional collector value. Good luck.