You will probably shoot the pigeon gun better, especially if you are a larger fellow. I have never had one so I am envious. I have some Spanish game guns in 12, 20 and 28. I can shoot the 28 fine at doves etc but when jogging after blue quail it is too light for me to handle and I do not shoot it near as well as a 12. My point is that I think that most people shoot a heavier gun better. I know that I do.