I think you have two answers to the question you have originally asked. I think I even gave you the basis for the math you requested.
I will recap for you:
GCMS says, “$1000-$2500”
I say, “$1200” with a shrug and, “if you’re lucky.”
Remember you are neither pricing, nor selling “uniqueness.” You are likely pricing a very plumb colored, poorly preserved relic that might be super cool, but may also just be a larger version of typical scrap.
“Surprisingly good” and “with no repairs” aren’t exactly boasts of high condition and at 32 inches on a 6 bore —shortening seems better than possible, maybe even “surprisingly likely.”Now that wouldn’t classify as a repair would it ?
Love to see it Ed. Take those “pitchers” and show it to us.