1. Moose, 2. Whitetail/Pronghorn (tie), 3.Mule Deer, 4. Elk, 5. Black bear.

To be fair the only Elk I've ever eaten were killed & cooked by my late BIL Bubba Magnumitis & all the Moose were from Northern Ontario. I've heard great things about both Elk & Black bear but not experienced it. The Black bear experience was limited to 2 & both were late fall kills & not over bait/carrion or near dumps (one killed foraging in a blueberry patch).