Buy them both. Shoot them both, hard, for a year. Three years would be better.
At the end of the three year period, one will sort out to be the better candidate. Sell the other. If both work out well, keep both, and let your heirs figure out what to do with them after you croak with custody of two decent guns, or sell the one that is in a state of lower condition. If you don't know at the end of three years of use which works out better for you, you haven't shot them enough.
I don't know how anybody could tell you which gun to buy and use without seeing either of them, or, you.
A slight aside based on personal observation, I don't care for strikers that are integral with the tumblers. I think both of these guns fall into that catagory, however.
Good luck.
Best,
Ted
