James, it sounds as if some of the very best mentioned in this thread have rock hard footbeds, stitching that tears after only a couple years, or leaky uppers that will leave you with wet feet when walking through wet grass. I absolutely agree with the idea of buying quality boots, but price and prestige does not always translate into comfort and durability.
I kind of understand BrentD on this subject. From a quick glance in my basement last night, I'd say I probably have at least 14-15 pairs of hunting boots ranging from light leather and uninsulated rubber to heavy Gore-Tex and Thinsulate lined, felt pac, or insulated rubber Mickey Mouse boots for sub-zero conditions. None is perfect for all hunting, but I have come to prefer some over others, and the most expensive have not always been the best, most comfortable, or most durable. The final choice for the day always comes down to the conditions and the type of hunting I plan to do. Then I usually toss an extra pair of boots and socks in the truck for those days when you break through the ice up to your knee and fill your boot with cold black swamp water.
I do find it mildly amusing when I see some teeny tiny women's shoes selling for $500.00 to $1000.00 when I can buy good work or hunting boots that have half a cow's worth of leather for a fraction of the price. The women don't bat an eye.
