I had both BSSs and 23s in 12 and 20 gauges and, a 23 in 28 gauge, and I thought they handled and shot more alike than different. The only one I have left is the BSS Sporter 20 gauge with 28" barrels. They were both more in the American style designed for heavier loads, than the English game gun style, even the small gauge 23s. I tend to shoot heavier loads so they were good for me. Never had a seconds trouble with either, but the BSS was my favorite.