Sorry to say...I will say no contract exists. From the Docs facts, the parties were still negotiating, counter offers, counter acceptance...then the last one where the figure goes between $25 and 30 thou....no acceptance , just agreement to meet....forget the cashing of the check, her lawyer would simply say that she cashed the check to safe guard the funds.....did not want to lose the check, etc, etc.Newberg is right on. I too do not think there is a cause of action. No only that, Doc sends an email...saying that there was a misunderstanding on BOTH sides. Her lawyer would say this guy knew the gun was worth more than the E grade..he is the president of a shotgun collectors association, etc. etc....the discusions were all over the place...she panicked....wondering if she was wrong on its value.Doc kept wanting to deal, changed his price though the discusions....the point is, no meeting of the minds...still ongoing negotiations....no final agreement.... No specific permance or damages....." But your honor, he called ,my client a crook by comparing her to a drug dealer ..he slandered her your Honor.., and libeled her by enticing others to make entries on her face book page...it is all here" "....I know what doc said in his description, but, see how this stuff can turn ugly...I just played the devils advocate...That is about it...Doc should be happy he got his money back.
Last edited by Condor; 01/26/14 12:29 AM.
