Great thread Michael:
One thing you didn't mention above regarding buggered(plain) screws. Often I've found that all the metal is still there it's just been "relocated" a bit. When I get a screw in this condition it goes into a padded vice where I'll try to tap the dislocated metal back where it belongs as much as possible.
I then will finish the screw basically as you described above.
Jim

The 2nd Amendment IS an unalienable right.