Originally Posted By: Geno
What you could suggest for 1 year pointing dog, what is the best on the market today?
Actually I'm not going to use e-colar all the time, beeper mostly, but young dog got some bad habits such as running behind small birds and very far away. My persuasions and strap got no effect on him - too healthy and too smart dog thou


Geno,

I have no idea what experience you may have had with e-collars. However, it will not fix the problems you are talking about. Only going back to basic training will fix these things. A big running dog can not be controlled with an e-collar. It is a matter of displine. When you call the dog or whistle, it has to come to you. Questing after the "wrong" birds will never be fixed by the use of an e-collar. If anything, you will cause the dog to "blink" or worse, make the dog totally bird shy.

A beep on demand collar is nice. I use them on both of my dogs. However, I could just as easily use a bell, which I some times do. I always use a whistle. I have not had to shock a dog in almost over 2 years.

Pete