Sportdog. I had done some research on the different collars, Dogtra, Innotex and Tritronics were all looked at. I came to like the way the Sportdog was made. I can have the e-collar on with the beeper, or just the beeper or just the e-colloar. A lot of them it is all one piece, cannot take the beeper off. Beeper is also controlled by the remote. The model I got was the 1850, priced like the rest, around $380.00.
Their bark collar only weighs 1.5 oz. compared to Dogtras which is about 3 times the size and weight.