I don't call that a nuanced situation, more like common sense, Doverham! I take the best gun for the mission regardless of its condition and value IF I can get to the blind by foot or boat.
Gunning on the offshore kelp-covered ledges where it hard to be safe on your feet is always a retreat to another double. The gun, however, is so much of the experience that I can't bring myself to use a beater, a tool. It's always a good gun
King: I may have used the wrong term describing my Browning Superposed as a 'beater'. I have used this gun sooooo much it really is just an extension of me, sort of like a well-fitted pair of old gloves. Browning superposed are excellent guns in my opinion and real value for the money. The one I have is all beat up, the stock has numerous scratches and the bluing is well worn, esp on the receiver.....but the gun still functions perfectly and shoots exactly where I'm looking. I have killed 2 TRUE Ruffed Grouse doubles with this gun and lots of game in general. A Browning Superposed is a FINE gun in my opinion...and not a 'beater'. In fact they are made of demibloc or chopper lump construction which as you know is a characteristic of an excellent gun. I should have used another term for this fine, fine gun. I like side x side shotguns too, though. Cheers, Buzz
