I have the book, and its been around for a long time (mid-80s maybe?). Like all other McIntosh books, it is written in his unique style; and is a fun read (basically, a series of short stories on his ideas of which shotguns should make the list and why he arrived at his conclusions). However, if you are looking for a book that will provide indepth information on a particular brand/s, which is what most collectors seek; this is not the reference book you want.