Goretex does eventually break down, but I prefer it to rubber. Hunting pheasants in Iowa most of my life, I had to wear rubber quite often, but can't say I ever liked it. I've had good luck with the Cabela's upland boots. I treat the leather uppers, which I think helps the Goretex last longer. I've had to have a couple pairs of those resoled, and usually for me, the uppers go before the soles.