I had always wanted a Beretta SXS shotgun, and after getting some help from several members of this board I finally managed to find a 12 gauge 626 Onyx in good condition and bought it last summer. I found that the gun fit me well and I have enjoyed using it. It was my dove gun last season and I hope to use it again this year. I shoot it reasonably well on clays; about as well as I shoot anything.
A few months ago I had the chance to buy a 425 12 gauge in reasonable condition at what I thought was a good price, so I bought it. It was made in 1968, which according to one of Jim Bode's excellent publications would have been during the time that Garcia was importing the GR line into the USA, and the 425 was not sold here then. It has sling swivels, so it appears to have been made for a different market. I've no idea how it got here, but here it is:
When I first shouldered it, I could tell it didn't fit me at all. The 626 with its high rib has me looking right down the rib when I shoulder it, but I see a lot of the barrel with the 425. In order to look down the rib on it, I have to drop my head in an awkward position. I brought it home and set up the clay thrower and proceeded to miss 5 straight going away shots. I took it to a pattern board and found that it shoots about 6" low at 25 yards if I look down the rib and see only the bead.
I added fiber optic sights to the rib to show me how much barrel I need to see, and can shoot it a little better now, though not well enough to have the confidence in it to use it for anything.
Here is my question: Is this a simple case of the gun not fitting me, or is the gun flawed because it doesn't shoot true to the rib?
I've always been of the opinion that when you look down the rib, a shotgun should either center the pattern on the bead, or the bead should be somewhere between centered and the 6 o'clock position of the pattern. For the bead to be at the 12 o'clock position of the pattern seems like a flaw in the gun to me.
I know I could add a rib to it and make the gun more usable, and I might do that. I have considered making it into a turkey gun where I am only shooting at a stationary target with it. However, testing showed that it acts like most light SXS guns with heavy turkey loads - the right barrel shoots to the right and the left barrel shoots to the left. I could solve that problem by filing the end of the chokes, but it would then shoot all other loads far out of alignment.
If the gun is flawed, as I think, I don't mind so much filing the chokes. It looks like its seen very little use, and I suspect that's because it shot low for everyone else who has ever owned it. I wouldn't sell it to anyone unless they understood how it shot and were willing to deal with it. But if there is really nothing wrong with the gun and it just doesn't fit me, I hate to take a file to a Beretta. I'm sure the gun will outlive me and there will likely be many others to own it during its useful life. It would be better to just sell it if its nothing but a fit problem.
Thanks for any and all opinions!