I don't think your question has one answer. It's not a stupid question, just one that would vary from shop to shop, whether the gun is new or used, How long he's had the gun, on consignment or part of the dealer's inventory, how you conduct yourself and even how the dealer feels on that particular day. The polite way to test the water about negotiations might be something like, "is the price firm"?, "do you have any flexibility on the price"? or any similar phrase. If you start off with "I just love this gun and I have to have it" you can be sure there won't be any negotiations after that. As to your example, I wouldn't hesitate to offer $4000 for a used gun marked $4500, if you think $4000 is reasonable. You won't get $500 off on a new gun because there probably isn't that much margin in the price. One very important thing: if you make an offer, be prepared to whip out your money if it is accepted. Stand on your hind legs and back up your words. Don't come back with some crap about asking your wife, or some other getaway excuse. Making offers should be sincere and honored, just like an auction. If the gun says $4500, you offer $4000, dealer says OK, fercrysakes don't ask then if he'd take $3500. He'll be correct in telling you to go home to your playstation and don't come back unless you're accompanied by an adult.
Last edited by Jim Legg; 01/25/07 09:08 PM.