Max-
Just like you and Rich--I had a shotgun that had the wrong length of pull (LOP) and I was not hitting much with it. I followed the advice in the below quoted article and I adjusted my shotgun's LOP and pitch (pitch is also discussed in this short article) by adding a pitch spacer and recoil pad. I made a bit of an allowance for the fact that my shotgun had two triggers by making a bit of a compromise between the LOP being a tad long for the front trigger position and a tad short the rear trigger position of my right hand (but keeping my thumb off my nose). What the article points out is that not all people are built the same so the fact that someone your height but with a different build, might do just fine with your shotgun's current LOP. Anyway, following the advice in the article worked like magic for me, so I pass it along for what it may be worth.
Doug
“The critical dimension in judging the correct LOP for an individual is that there should be about one inch to an inch-and-a-quarter of space between the thumb and nose when the gun is mounted, cheeked and ready to fire. This is a measurement that you can't make on yourself, but is one easily made by someone else. This is the one constant -- in a sea of variables that will be the same if you are measuring your son, daughter, wife or shooting buddy. But circumstances alter cases.
The same guy suited up in a down hunting jacket for ptarmigan at North Pole, Alaska is going to have different LOP requirements than he is for shooting dove on the Mexican border in shirtsleeves. Tall guys with longer necks will probably need more than a 15" LOP. Guys who could play at tackle for the Chicago Bears, with no visible neck, might be perfectly happy with a 13-3/4" LOP. Reaching a decision with multi-variables to work with involves holding your Philosopher's Stone tightly and reaching the first of many compromises life will require of you.”
http://www.gundogsonline.com/Article/You-and-me-and-the-LOP-Length-of-Pull-Page1.htm