In a DIY forum, there would be the ability to have threads that are much more specific, in regard to materials and techniques. Instead of a generic "Stock Finishing" thread, there's opportunity to break the processes down by materials and techniques used. For instance, individual threads regarding "Tru-Oil", "French Polish", "Linseed Oil", "Traditional English Finish", as well as specific processes used by manufacturers could be created. That way each thread wouldn't become a debate over personal preferences. These threads then would be easily referenced.
Threads can also be clearly differentiated by the specific terms of "Repair", "Refinish" and "Restoration". For example, it would be inappropriate to describe use of Tru-Oil on a Vintage gun as "Restoration", but would certainly qualify as "Refinishing".
In many cases, a non traditional finish on a Vintage gun may be more appropriate. If one has a Parker, and intends to use it quite a bit, making the decision to use a more modern finish may be appropriate. It's certainly arguable that a Tru-Oil finish would be more practical than a traditional shellac and wax one, which would require much more attention to maintain.
Last edited by Ken61; 06/06/15 07:51 PM.
