Thanks to all for the information. PAs barrels look better what I have produced so far. They look better than any barrels I own!

Until I went looking on the internet I simply followed the instructions that come with the Pilkington Classic American Rust Blue. I dont think there is any mention of a soda wash.

I will take some photos this weekend so you guys can assess my current attempt. Hopefully you will not mind looking at an 1897 Winchester. I was trying for more of a matt finish and only polished to 320.

I thought the rusting agent was almost certainly water soluble (most acids are). Next time

Thanks again.

Last edited by RyanF; 10/11/12 03:23 PM.