My decision to return (as a buyer) or accept a return (as a seller) always revolves around "what goes around comes around". I sold an A. H. Fox which I had owned and shot for several years. The buyer emailed me about a week after receiving it (WITH PHOTOS) telling me the left barrel let go right in front of the chamber! He stated he was using new AA traploads and included a photo of the shell both in and out of the split barrel. He sent the gun and the remainder of the unfired shells to be analyzed. Apparently the barrel had an internal flaw when manufactured - not my fault or his. I offered to refund his money, even though I felt I had no personal liability. When the folks who did the analysis shipped the gun back to him, the stock and receiver were severely damaged. Long story short, he collected more than he paid for the gun from the carrier, it cost me nothing and we were both happy. It could have gone in an ugly direction.

LCSMITH